NCAA Tournament Appearances |
| 2018 |
| 2017 |
| 2009 |
NCAA Tournament Wins |
| 2018 - First Round, 4-1 vs. Westminster (Pa.) |
| 2017 - First Round, 2-1 (2OT) vs. Dominican (Ill.) |
OAC Regular Season Championships |
| 2018 |
| 2008 |
| 2007 |
| 1989 |
| 1987 |
OAC Tournament Championships |
| 2009 |
NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches All-Americans |
| Chewy Gordon, 2018 (1st) |
| Steven McCarthy, 2007 (2nd) |
| Steven McCarthy, 2009 (3rd) |
D3soccer.com All-Americans |
| Chewy Gordon, 2018 (2nd) |
NSCAA Scholar All-Americans |
| Justin Niswonger, 2017 |
| Bob Weisgarber, 2013 |
United Soccer Coaches Team Academic Award
2003
2011
NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches All-Great Lakes Region |
||
| 2019 | 2018 | |
| Brandon Woo (3rd) | Chewy Gordon (1st) | |
| Daniel Bundschuh (2nd) | ||
| Greg Knox (2nd) | ||
| 2017 | 2016 | 2015 |
| Justin Niswonger (3rd) | Jacob Pulliam (2nd) | Jacob Pulliam (3rd) |
| Chewy Gordon (3rd) | Alexander Basiakos (2nd) | |
| 2014 | 2013 | 2010 |
| R.G. Florey (3rd) | Bob Weisgarber (2nd) | Dan McCarthy (2nd) |
| 2009 | 2008 | 2007 |
| Steven McCarthy (1st) | Steven McCarthy (1st) | John Snyder |
| Dan McCarthy (2nd) | Dan McCarthy (3rd) | Paul Sparke |
| Steven McCarthy | ||
NSCAA Great Lakes Region Coach of the Year |
| Dwight Burgess, 2007 |
D3kicks.com All-Great Lakes Region |
| Steven McCarthy, 2006 (2nd) |
OSCA Division III Player of the Year |
| Steven McCarthy, 2007 |
OSCA Division III Coach of the Year |
| Dwight Burgess, 2007 |
OAC GOALTENDER OF THE YEAR |
| Justin Niswonger, 2017 |
| Bob Weisgarber, 2013 |
| John Snyder, 2007 |
OAC DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR |
| Alexander Basiakos, 2016 |
OAC MIDFIELDER OF THE YEAR |
| Jacob Pulliam, 2016 |
| Dan McCarthy, 2008 |
OAC FORWARD OF THE YEAR |
| Chewy Gordon, 2018 |
| Steven McCarthy, 2009 |
| Steven McCarthy, 2008 |
OAC COACH OF THE YEAR |
| Alan Yost, 2018 |
| Dwight Burgess, 2009 |
| Dwight Burgess, 2005 |
| Rudd McGary, 1987 |
OAC CLYDE LAMB AWARD RECIPIENT |
| Bob Weisgarber, 2013 |
| Mark Dunn, 1993 |
ALL-OAC |
||
| 2019 | 2018 | |
| Brandon Woo (2nd) | Chewy Gordon (1st) | |
| Mitch Hughes (2nd) | Greg Knox (1st) | |
| Greg Knox (HM) | Daniel Bundschuh (1st) | |
| Tristan Bentley (2nd) | ||
| Luke Morais (HM) | ||
| Cole Moscovic (HM) | ||
| Logan Wiedman (HM) | ||
| 2017 | 2016 | 2015 |
| Justin Niswonger (1st) | Jacob Pulliam (1st) | Jacob Pulliam (1st) |
| Chewy Gordon (1st) | Alexander Basiakos (1st) | Alexander Basiakos (2nd) |
| Dominic Zumpone (2nd) | Cheyn Roux (2nd) | Calvin Saunders (2nd) |
| Greg Knox (2nd) | Hunter Booth (2nd) | Justin Niswonger (HM) |
| Luke Morais (HM) | Justin Niswonger (2nd) | Mario Suarez (HM) |
| Daniel Bundschuh (HM) | Chewy Gordon (HM) | |
| Trevor Collins (HM) | Josh McDaniel (HM) | |
| 2014 | 2013 | 2012 |
| R.G. Florey (1st) | Bob Weisgarber (1st) | Al Argyris (2nd) |
| Austin Dent (2nd) | R.G. Florey (2nd) | R.G. Florey (HM) |
| Josh Spaw (HM) | Nick Eley (HM) | Nick Eley (HM) |
| Calvin Saunders (HM) | Jacob Pulliam (HM) | |
| Cheyn Roux (HM) | Austin Dent (HM) | |
| Jacob Pulliam (HM) | ||
| 2011 | 2010 | 2009 |
| Luke Froehlich (HM) | Dan McCarthy (2nd) | Steven McCarthy (1st) |
| Nick Eley (HM) | Kevin Doran (HM) | Dan McCarthy (1st) |
| Ian Warmbrodt (2nd) | ||
| Robbie Breen (2nd) | ||
| 2008 | 2007 | 2006 |
| Steven McCarthy (1st) | Steven McCarthy (1st) | Steven McCarthy (1st) |
| Dan McCarthy (1st) | Paul Sparke (1st) | John Snyder (2nd) |
| Josh Thaboune (2nd) | John Snyder (1st) | Paul Sparke (2nd) |
| John Snyder (2nd) | Josh Thaboune (HM) | Robbie Breen (2nd) |
| Kevin Doran (2nd) | ||
| 2005 | 2004 | 2003 |
| Tony Miller (2nd) | Josh Racette (HM) | Michael Baughn (2nd) |
| Joey Snyder (HM) | Heath Oberle (HM) | Nick Peters (HM) |
| Dan Albiet (HM) | Tony Miller (HM) | |
| John Snyder (HM) | ||
| 2002 | 2001 | 1999 |
| Richie Allen (HM) | Nick Peters (HM) | David Cron (HM) |
| Nick Peters (HM) | ||
| Michael Baughn (HM) | ||
| 1993 | 1992 | 1991 |
| Greg Van Kannel (1st) | Greg Van Kannel (1st) | Greg Van Kannel (1st) |
| 1990 | 1989 | 1988 |
| Jeff Flamm (1st) | Jamie Peters (1st) | Ron Behrman (1st) |
| Mark Dunn (1st) | Jeff Flamm (1st) | Jeff Flamm (1st) |
| Greg Van Kannel (1st) | ||
| 1987 | 1986 | 1985 |
| Ron Behrman (1st) | Dave Pecoraro (1st) | Steve Williams (1st) |
| Jeff Dornsife (1st) | Ron Behrman (1st) | Ron Behrman (1st) |
| Jeff Flamm (1st) | ||
| 1984 | 1979 | 1977 |
| Steve Williams (1st) | John Ploeger (1st) | Craig Knechtel (1st) |
| Jeff Dornsife (1st) | ||
| Steve Gibson (1st) | ||
ACADEMIC ALL-OAC |
||
| 2019 | 2018 | |
| Chase Geddis | Brandon Woo | |
| Greg Knox | Daniel Bundschuh | |
| Cole Hamilton | Cole Moscovic | |
| Majd Awad | Cole Hamilton | |
| Brandon Woo | Shane Niemeier | |
| Shane Niemeier | Greg Knox | |
| Cole Moscovic | ||
| 2017 | 2016 | 2015 |
| Daniel Bundschuh | Daniel Bundschuh | Brennan Uhrig |
| Cole Moscovic | Calvin Saunders | Josh Spaw |
| Greg Knox | Jacob Pulliam | Cody Circle |
| Hunter Booth | Cheikh Tandiang | |
| Jacob Pulliam | ||
| Hunter Booth | ||
| Calvin Saunders | ||
| Nick Hernandez | ||
| 2014 | 2013 | 2012 |
| Brad Brown | Joe Alecusan | Joe Alecusan |
| Zac Matheny | Tony Macioce | Al Argyris |
| Jacob Pulliam | Andrew Rutsky | Derek Cox |
| Cody Circle | Bob Weisgarber | Aaron Ingle |
| Josh Spaw | Craig Shimer | Tony Macioce |
| Hunter Booth | Josh Spaw | Andrew Rutsky |
| Bob Weisgarber | ||
| 2011 | 2010 | 2009 |
| Bob Weisgarber | Dan McCarthy | Dan McCarthy |
| Dan McCarthy | Jeremy Sampson | Jeremy Sampson |
| Ian Warmbrodt | Ian Warmbrodt | |
| 2008 | 2007 | 2006 |
| Josh Thaboune | Paul Sparke | Paul Sparke |
| 2005 | 2003 | 1998 |
| Paul Sparke | Michael Baughn | Paul Garinger |
| John Mersfelder | ||
| 1997 | 1996 | 1995 |
| Jason Given | Dana Noffsinger | Dana Noffsinger |
| 1992 | 1991 | 1990 |
| Daniel Leeper | Daniel Leeper | Mark Dunn |
| Mark Dunn | James Peters | Collin Thomas |
| 1989 | 1988 | 1987 |
| James Peters | Ron Behrman | Ron Behrman |
| Jeff Meyer | ||
OAC All-Tournament Team |
||
| 2018 | 2017 | |
| Chewy Gordon | Justin Niswonger | |
| Luke Morais | Dominic Zumpone | |
| Hunter Stiger | ||
OCSA Division III All-Ohio |
||
| 2018 | ||
| Chewy Gordon (1st) | ||
| Daniel Bundschuh (1st) | ||
| Greg Knox (2nd) | ||
| 2017 | 2016 | 2015 |
| Justin Niswonger (1st) | Alexander Basiakos (1st) | Jacob Pulliam (2nd) |
| Greg Knox (2nd) | Jacob Pulliam (1st) | Alexander Basiakos (3rd) |
| Chewy Gordon (2nd) | Cheyn Roux (2nd) | |
| Dominic Zumpone (3rd) | Justin Niswonger (3rd) | |
| 2014 | 2013 | 2012 |
| R.G. Florey (2nd) | Bob Weisgarber (2nd) | Al Argyris (3rd) |
| 2011 | 2010 | 2009 |
| Dan McCarthy (3rd) | Dan McCarthy (2nd) | Steven McCarthy (1st) |
| Josh Thaboune (3rd) | Dan McCarthy (2nd) | |
| Ian Warmbrodt (3rd) | ||
| 2008 | 2007 | 2006 |
| Steven McCarthy (1st) | John Snyder (1st) | Steven McCarthy (1st) |
| Dan McCarthy (2nd) | Paul Sparke (1st) | Paul Sparke (3rd) |
| John Snyder (3rd) | Steven McCarthy (1st) | |
OCSA Division III Academic All-Ohio |
||
| 2018 | 2017 | |
| Daniel Bundschuh (1st) | Justin Niswonger (1st) | |
| Greg Knox (1st) | ||
| 2015 | 2014 | 2013 |
| Jacob Pulliam (1st) | Josh Spaw (2nd) | Bob Weisgarber (1st) |
| Josh Spaw (3rd) | ||
OAC Player of the Week (since 2014) |
||
| 2018 | 2016 | 2014 |
| Chewy Gordon (10/22) | Justin Niswonger (10/3) | R.G. Florey (10/6) |
| Shane Niemeier (10/22) | Justin Niswonger (9/26) | |
| Logan Wiedman (10/8) | ||
| Chewy Gordon (10/1) | ||
| Logan Wiedman (9/17) | ||
| Chewy Gordon (9/10) | ||
